Skip to main content arrow-down arrow-tail-right arrow-triangle-right calendar camera compass download email eye facebook flag mail phone pin play send square-right tag twitter youtube badge message

PRESS RELEASE - Privy Council refuses to allow Cayman Government to hold secret hearings in prisoner transfer case

  • News
  • 3 Mar 2023


Today, 3 March 2023, we have received the judgment of the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council (JCPC) sitting in the Cayman Islands, allowing our client’s challenge to the Governor General’s insistence on holding closed hearings of a judicial review.

In 2016 our client Justin Ramoon, was convicted of murder and possession of an unlicenced firearm and was subsequently sentenced to life imprisonment. In 2017, the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs (UK) authorised his transfer from the Cayman Islands to a prison in the UK, a country with which he had no ties, under the ‘Colonial Prisoners Act 1884’. This has seriously impacted upon Mr Ramoon’s ability to have a close relationship with his family, including his young son.

Mr Ramoon and his brother brought a judicial review of the decision of the Cayman Islands Governor to permit his transfer to the United Kingdom. During these proceedings, the Governor of the Cayman Islands and Director of Prisons (the Respondents) refused to disclose relevant evidence, claiming that it would undermine national security to do so.

The Respondents convinced the Court of Appeal that a Closed Material Procedure (CMP) should be held, allowing the court to consider evidence which was withheld from Mr Ramoon and his brother, excluding them from the hearings.

Appealing to the Privy Council, Mr Ramoon argued that there was no legal basis for the courts to hold a CMP and the resulting proceedings would be inherently unfair. During the appeal, the Respondents argued that if the Grand Court in the Cayman Islands could not hold a CMP, then Mr Ramoon’s claim should be dismissed. The Governor argued it would be unfair for the court not to see the evidence which they refused to share with Mr Ramoon.

Today, the Privy Council have determined that it is “…simply not open to [the courts] to invent a CMP for the Cayman Islands.” The Board explained that due to the inherent unfairness of CMPs to individuals, Parliament is better placed to “…assess the policy considerations relating to the necessity for such a procedure…and to make detailed procedural rules to regulate the procedure.

Dismissing the Respondents’ request to strike out the claim, the Board held that the claim should now proceed to trial, solely on the basis of the material which the Respondents were willing to disclose.

Responding to the judgment Prathna Bodden of Samson Law said

This is a significant development in Mr Ramoon’s long-running battle challenging the decision that he serve his sentence in the United Kingdom. We welcome the Privy Council’s ruling that the government cannot hold secret hearings, without express authority. This is a victory for open justice and fairness in the courts of the Cayman Islands.

From the Death Penalty Project, Saul Lehrfreund said

“The Privy Council’s ruling that CMPs cannot take place without proper guidelines and defined procedure upholds important fair trial rights. Excluding individuals from trials should only ever be a last resort. We are pleased that this decision will create a fairer and more transparent justice system.”

Notes to Editors

JCPC Judgment

Court Sitting

This appeal was heard during the sitting of the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council (JCPC) between 15-18 November 2022, in the Cayman Islands. This was the first time that the JCPC have sat in an Overseas Territory of the United Kingdom.

Closed Material Procedures (CMPs)

A CMP is a procedure by which a government or public body is permitted to rely on evidence which is not disclosed to the other party to litigation, on public interest or national security grounds. A court will consider this evidence in “closed” sessions where the individual and their legal representatives are excluded from the hearing. In such circumstances, the court will appoint a “special advocate”, an independent lawyer who does not represent the individual, but who is permitted to see and comment on the closed material, independently from the public body.

The Legal Team

The appellant was represented by  Hugh Southey KC (Matrix Chambers), Prathna Bodden (Partner at Samson Law Associates) instructed by the Death Penalty Project.

Death Penalty Project

The Death Penalty Project (DPP) is a legal action NGO, based at Simons Muirhead Burton LLP, with special consultative status before the United Nations Economic and Social Council. For more than three decades, the DPP has worked to protect the rights of those facing the death penalty.

For interview requests, quotes or more information please contact Isobelle Degale, The Death Penalty Project, Communications Officer, [email protected]

Latest news

“Serious breach of procedural fairness” - excessive manslaughter sentence quashed in The Bahamas
Read More
Ghana Web: Alban Bagbin praised for repeal of death penalty
Read More
IBAHRI commends abolition of the death penalty - Ghana
Read More
CLA Statement: Commending the Zambian and Ghanaian Governments for Abolishing the Death Penalty
Read More
The Week: Ghana abolishes the death penalty
Read More
The Guardian: Ghana abolishes death penalty, with expected reprieve for 176 condemned prisoners
Read More
DPP INTERVIEW: Francis-Xavier Sosu, the Ghanaian MP whose private member’s Bills have abolished the death penalty in Ghana
Read More
DPP interview with TRT - "Why are executions on the rise in a number of countries?"
Read More
Jurist: Ghana Parliament votes to end death penalty
Read More
The Washington Post: Ghana votes to remove the death penalty, calling it sign of ‘inhumane’ society
Read More
NGO welcomes abolition of the Death Penalty in Ghana
Read More
BBC News: Ghana Parliament votes to abolish death penalty
Read More
PRESS RELEASE: A Huge Win for Human Rights - Ghana Abolishes the Death Penalty
Read More
Ghana abolishing death penalty is a huge win for human rights – DPP
Read More
THE CONVERSATION AFRICA: It’s time for Ghana to enshrine its respect for the right to life – by abolishing the death penalty
Read More
NEW Op-ed: It’s time for Ghana to enshrine its respect for right to life – by abolishing death penalty
Read More
“Another instance where the justice system has failed a person”: Privy Council recognises multiple failures in Jamaica’s appeal processes
Read More
CLA Support Death Penalty Abolition Advocacy in Ghana
Read More
VIDEO: Privy council quashes convictions after man spends 12 years in jail
Read More

Stay up-to-date with our work