Skip to main content arrow-down arrow-tail-right arrow-triangle-right calendar camera compass download email eye facebook flag mail phone pin play send square-right tag twitter youtube badge message

Press Release: Privy Council Allows Appeals in Two Key Death Penalty Cases

  • News
  • 4 Mar 2008

LESTER PITMAN

Lester Pitman’s appeal to the Privy Council has been allowed on the basis of new medical evidence which may cast doubt on the safety of his conviction for murder and the legality of the sentence of death.

The case has been remitted to the Court of Appeal of Trinidad and Tobago after the Privy Council admitted the fresh evidence about Pitman’s mental state. The Court of Appeal will now have to consider the safety of the conviction and the legality of the sentence in light of that evidence.

According to the new medical evidence, Pitman has an IQ of 52. A result below 70 is generally considered to show severe mental impairment. Psychiatric tests show that he is also extremely compliant and suggestible. This new evidence may cast doubt on the value of his confession, which was made in the police station without the presence of a lawyer or family member, whether he is fit to plead, whether he has a defence of diminished responsibility, and the legality of passing a death sentence on him.

In June 2005, Trinidad read Pitman a warrant of execution while his appeal to the Privy Council was pending. Only an emergency order from the High Court of Trinidad saved his life.

The Appellant was represented by Edward Fitzgerald QC of Doughty Street Chambers and Alison Macdonald of Matrix Chambers who were instructed by Simons, Muirhead & Burton.

 

LESLIE PIPERSBURGH AND PATRICK ROBATEAU

Leslie Pipersburgh and Patrick Robateau have had their convictions for four murders and an attempted murder quashed. Both had been sentenced to death.
At their original trial, the prosecution relied heavily on five dock identifications of Pipersburgh and Robateau. The judge failed to direct the jury adequately in relation to this evidence, which is generally considered to be extremely unreliable. It was primarily because of this failure that their Lordships held that the convictions were unsafe.

The Privy Council went on to clarify the correct procedure for dealing with alleged admissions made to ‘persons in authority’ who are not police officers.

Lord Rodger also gave guidelines on the appropriate sentencing procedure when a discretionary death sentence is being considered. His Lordship emphasised the need to obtain social enquiry and psychiatric reports for every prisoner being considered for a death sentence. These help inform the decision as to whether there is any possibility of a prisoner reforming and readapting to society. In recent capital cases elsewhere in the Caribbean it has been held that a discretionary death sentence should only be passed in exceptional circumstances and only when there is no possibility of reform or social re­adaptation.

Given its conclusion that the convictions were unsafe, the Privy Council did not need to rule on whether the sentences of death by hanging would constitute inhuman and degrading punishment and that the carrying out of those sentences would accordingly be unconstitutional.

The case has been remitted to the Court of Appeal of Belize, which will decide whether Pipersburgh and Robateau must face a fresh trial.

The Appellants were represented by Edward Fitzgerald QC of Doughty Street Chambers, Simeon Sampson SC of the Belize Bar and Alex Bailin of Matrix Chambers who were instructed by Simons, Muirhead & Burton.

Latest news

The Conversation: 'Why has Kenya not abolished the death penalty? Habit and inertia'
Read More
Political and legal issues: reflections on our report launch in Kenya, Nairobi
Read More
Efforts towards Abolition: Our recent trip to Ghana
Read More
There is strong evidence Kenyans want abolition of death penalty
Read More
New research examines Kenyan attitudes towards the death penalty
Read More
As Africa rapidly turns away from capital punishment, is it time for Kenya to abolish this relic of a colonial past?
Read More
Challenge to the constitutionality of the mandatory death penalty in Trinidad and Tobago dismissed by UK Privy Council
Read More
Lescene Edwards's murder conviction overturned by the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council
Read More
A punishment reserved for the poor and marginalised? New study shines light on the profiles and experiences of death row inmates in Bangladesh
Read More
The Death Penalty Project pays tribute to Professor Nigel Eastman
Read More
Taiwan’s legislators hold the key to abolition as new research reveals the majority favour an end to capital punishment
Read More
The Death Penalty Project pays tribute to Nancy Anderson
Read More
UK’s Privy Council set to hear important challenge to constitutionality of the mandatory death penalty in Trinidad and Tobago
Read More
Indonesians’ support for the death penalty declines with more rigorous survey methods
Read More
The Kalisher Trust Legal Internship - Applications now open
Read More
World Day Against the Death Penalty - Women and the Death Penalty
Read More
People may change mind about death penalty, but government?
Read More
Dismantle the gallows! Sierra Leone becomes the latest country to abolish the death penalty
Read More

Stay up-to-date with our work