Skip to main content arrow-down arrow-tail-right arrow-triangle-right calendar camera compass download email eye facebook flag mail phone pin play send square-right tag twitter youtube badge message

Privy Council Rule that Mandatory Death Sentence for 'Felony' Murder is 'Cruel and Unusual Punishment' in Trinidad and Tobago and Quashes Death Sentence

  • News
  • 16 Jun 2011

In a judgment delivered on 15 June 2011, the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council ruled that the mandatory death sentence for felony murder is unconstitutional as it amounts to cruel and unusual treatment.

Their Lordships’ Board allowed the appeal on behalf of Mr. Nimrod Miguel, a prisoner on death row in from Trinidad & Tobago and quashed his mandatory sentence of death.

Mr. Miguel was convicted of felony murder (or more accurately “violent arrestable offence murder”) in January 2008, and his initial appeal to the Court of Appeal in Trinidad and Tobago was rejected in February 2009. Mr. Miguel appealed against his conviction and sentence to the Privy Council.

The imposition of the mandatory sentence of death on conviction for  participation in a “violent arrestable offence” is particularly harsh as all  persons involved in the offence are liable to be convicted of murder and  automatically sentenced to death, even if the killing was done without intent to  kill or to cause grievous bodily harm.

The Appellant’s mandatory sentence of death was quashed and he will now be entitled to a sentence hearing where the judge will have the discretion to impose an appropriate sentence taking all factors into account.

Saul Lehrfreund MBE and Parvais Jabbar, Human Rights Lawyers and Executive Directors of the Death Penalty Project who represented the Appellant state:

This important ruling could potentially assist many prisoners on death row who have been convicted of “violent arrestable offence murder” and were sentenced to the mandatory death penalty in Trinidad and Tobago. All such prisoners will now be entitled to the same remedy as Mr. Miguel and fall to be resentenced. Hopefully, the legislature will now take measures to remove the mandatory aspect of the death penalty from the statute books for all offences, including murder as it offends the Constitution and international human rights norms.

Notes to Editors:

1. Mr. Miguel was represented, on a pro bono basis, by James Dingemans QC and Daniel Tivadar from 3 Hare Court, instructed by Simons Muirhead & Burton.
2. The Death Penalty Project is an international human rights organisation housed and supported by Soho legal firm Simons Muirhead & Burton, providing free legal representation to many individuals still facing the death penalty in the Commonwealth. The organisation also receives generous support from the Sigrid Rausing Trust, the Oak Foundation, the UK Foreign & Commonwealth Office, the United Nations Voluntary Fund for Victims of Torture and by a grant from the Foundation of the Open Society Institute. For further information, please go to www.deathpenaltyproject.org.
3. For further information please contact Saul Lehrfreund MBE or Parvais Jabbar, Executive Directors of the Death Penalty Project Ltd at Simons Muirhead & Burton.

 

Latest news

Privy Council clarifies the approach trial judges should adopt when explaining “intent” to juries in The Bahamas
Read More
International Women's Day Q&A: Women in Human Rights
Read More
Cayman News Service: UK court rules against closed-door legal hearing
Read More
Cayman Loop News - Justin Ramoon, sentenced for murder, gets go ahead for judicial review
Read More
PRESS RELEASE - Privy Council refuses to allow Cayman Government to hold secret hearings in prisoner transfer case
Read More
Cayman Compass - Privy Council rules against secret trial for exiled killers
Read More
Cayman Marl Road - Privy Council refuses secret hearings in Cayman prisoner transfer case
Read More
NEW op-ed: Time to scrap capital punishment in Taiwan
Read More
Privy Council: Appeal dismissed amidst serious disclosure failings
Read More
James Guthrie, impressive barrister whose work in the Privy Council included a string of landmark cases – obituary
Read More
LATEST OP-ED: Hoyle & Jabbar - Death penalty doesn’t deter crime
Read More
New article in Kenya's The Star: Death row convicts in Kenya not threatened by penalty – findings
Read More
PRESS RELEASE - New research exploring socio-economic profiles of Kenya’s death row prisoners
Read More
Kenyan prisoners on death row weren’t deterred by the threat of the death penalty: new research findings
Read More
The Death Penalty Project pays tribute to James Guthrie KC
Read More
London-based NGO to challenge lawfulness of Guyana’s death penalty at CCJ
Read More
PRESS RELEASE - Guyana’s Court of Appeal refuses to declare the death penalty unconstitutional
Read More
The Conversation: 'Why has Kenya not abolished the death penalty? Habit and inertia'
Read More
Political and legal issues: reflections on our report launch in Kenya, Nairobi
Read More

Stay up-to-date with our work